Recently Councilor Staggers has aired his discontent with the tobacco free policy in SF parks, not because he doesn’t think it is a good idea but because 1) The city council should have passed the ordinance, not the Parks department & 2) Is it a finable offense? Good question. Staggers asked;
Dear Don, Many months ago we were told that there was no punishment for smoking in the parks. Now there is punishment, or is there? You mention the punishment for violation of city ordinances where no punishment is stipulated, however, the prohibition on smoking comes from a directive from the head of the Parks Department, and not from an ordinance. We should not have a situation where an individual can say that something is wrong and then have a person  fined and/or imprisoned. Only the City Council should be passing ordinances fining and/or imprisoning people
UPDATED: (I removed Kearney’s email context ) The ordinance as stated;
§ 95.032 AUTHORITY OF DIRECTOR TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN CONDUCT; NOTICE.
The director may prohibit conduct in those areas of the parks when and where the director deems conduct dangerous or unduly interfering with another’s use of the parks such as, but not limited to, picnicking areas. A notice prohibiting activity within a specific area shall be conspicuously displayed setting forth which activity, conduct, or games are restricted.
It seems director Kearney seems to think it is okay to not only MAKE the rules, but enforce them and if needed fine people. (All City Ordinances, unless otherwise provided, are punishable by a fine of up to $500 and/or imprisonment in the county jail of up to 30 days.)
Remember, city directors are appointed by the mayor, not elected officials.
Let’s leave ordinance approval up to the (elected) city council so Kearney can get back to doing more important things, like scraping goose manure off of the bike trails.
Are you shittin me?
Illegal to smoke a cigarette in a PARK?
I am NOT a smoker.
But WTF, gang – going a little nazi on us, dontcha think?
ZERO danger of second-hand smoke…
but YOU don’t like it so YOU decide you’re going to fine somebody $500 and 30 days in jail?
I guess power just RUSHES to some peoples heads faster than reason.
Get a grip, Kearney, you’re not a GOD.
Not sure if you ‘CAN’ be fined. I deleted the email correspondence from Kearney, because it on one hand he was saying they wouldn’t fine people, then he said as a city director he has the ‘authority’ to fine people if they are endangering others. As I have said in the past, why not just practice a little common courtesy? If someone is allergic or asmathic, it is dangerous to be around them, even outdoors, while smoking. But I believe a little common sense will prevent people from smoking around children in parks. I guess I have never taken issue with the smoke in parks, but the littering. I have never understood why smokers can’t walk two feet to a trash can to throw away their butts.